Malcolm Lewis's reviews for Heart Rate Monitors X

 (3)
Select a Tag (left) to change your search.   See also: Top-Rated Heart Rate Monitors
Garmin Premium Heart Rate Monitor Strap photo
Malcolm Lewis: More comfortable to wear than the traditional chest strap but still works just as well. Amazon currently selling them for $42, which is a 40% discount to the $70 list price.
Garmin Forerunner 110 photo
Malcolm Lewis: I have used a Garmin 405 to track my weekend long runs for about 1.5 years. Previously I owned the Garmin 305. I'm using the 110 with with my 405 chest strap (saved me $50) though I have the premium soft strap on order from Amazon (review coming!)

SUMMARY:
The 110 does everything I do with my 405 in a significantly smaller, lighter form factor with a superior GPS chip (in theory, to be proven).

REASONS WHY I LIKE MY NEW 110 BETTER THAN MY OLD 405:
* It's smaller and less bulky than the 405, looks and feels like a regular watch, and wraps snugly around my smallish wrist.

* I don't have to fiddle around with the temperamental 405 touch-(in)sensitive bezel.

* The displayed numbers for distance/hr/time/pace are bigger on the 110 than the 405, so easier for me to read on the run.

* There are fewer menus to navigate.

* Like the 405, GPS locking and accuracy works just fine, even under trees (more below).

* Like the 405, I can set the auto-lap to increment every 1 mile (other distances available).

* The 110 displays everything I want to track during and after my run.
- Elapsed distance (for run), Elapsed time (for run), Current HR, Average pace (for current lap), Last lap pace (displayed automatically for a few seconds after each lap), Average HR (for run), Average pace (for run). Average HR and pace for the entire run are show under "History" at the end of my run.

* To make this tangible, I can glance at the watch to see that so far I've run 2.1 miles in 21 minutes, my current HR is 160, my pace for the current mile (mile 3) is 9:56 and my pace for the last lap (mile 2) was 10:01. At the end of my run, I click through to "History" and see that my average HR for the entire run was 162bpm and my average pace was 9:54 minute miles. For me, currently, all I care about is keeping my HR in the 160-170bpm range (your range will probably be different) while trying to keep my pace under 10:00. In general, I suspect most runners will have the same requirements: Track your current HR to keep it within a target range while attempting to meet or beat a per-mile pace goal.

* The 110 has a longer battery life

* I never used the other 405 features like courses, virtual partner, etc. Ironically, I "customized" the 405 screens to pretty much do what the 110 displays by default (but cannot be changes).
Dawn Schall:
Is that all? :)
1 year, 3 months ago
Malcolm Lewis:
That's all for now ;)
1 year, 3 months ago
Garmin Forerunner 405 GPS Running Watch photo
Malcolm Lewis: Excellent GPS running watch for instant pace and distance. Also provides HR if you use the chest strap. Finds a signal quickly and stays locked. Highly recommended toy for runners. Excellent free website (http://connect.garmin.com/) for downloading and tracking all your runs with all the GPS, pace and HR data the watch provides for each run.

414ms